LimaCharlie vs Elastic Security: a SIEM and EDR alternative for MSSPs

Updated Reviewed by Charlton Swearingen, CBO

The main difference between LimaCharlie and Elastic Security is packaging. LimaCharlie gives every customer an isolated tenant with the same features, a year of hot, indexed data, and rules that run on each event. Elastic keeps the EDR response console, AI, automation, and long searchable retention in its top tiers, and detection rules run on a schedule.

There’s no cluster to size, and cloud security and email security live in the same tenant.

The quick verdict

Which should you choose: LimaCharlie or Elastic Security?

Choose LimaCharlie if

  • You want every customer on the same features, with no tier deciding whether analysts can isolate a host.
  • You want detections that fire on each event, with no polling window.
  • You don’t want to plan nodes, shards, or lifecycle policies for every customer.
  • You want to add products as you need them and pay only for what you use.

Elastic Security may fit better if

  • You want a free, self-hosted SIEM with malware prevention, and your team can run the clusters.
  • You want Elasticsearch as your search engine and Elastic’s large open rule repo.
  • You already run Elastic as your data lake.

At a glance

LimaCharlie vs Elastic Security: feature comparison

The main differences between the platforms, side by side.

LimaCharlie vs Elastic Security: feature comparison
CapabilityLimaCharlieElastic Security
Log pricingUsage-based, with a year of retention included. See current pricing →Serverless ingest from $0.09 to $0.11 per GB at volume, plus retention. Elastic’s own example starts Complete at $0.60 per GB for the first 50 GB [1]
A year of searchable dataIncluded, hot and fully indexedServerless keeps a 7-day search-ready window by default. On Hosted and self-managed, searchable cold and frozen tiers need Enterprise [2]
What you size and runNothingHosted and self-managed: nodes, tiers, shards, lifecycle policies, and upgrades [2]
How rules runOn every event as it arrives, typically under 100 msScheduled, with a look-back window. On Serverless, most rules stop after 1 minute per run [4]
Response from a ruleAny endpoint command, run from the rule that fired, within millisecondsAlert actions and Workflows. External actions need Gold, Workflows need Enterprise or Complete [5]
Endpoint response consoleEvery tierEnterprise (Hosted) or Complete (Serverless) [5]
Windows and Linux coverageWindows 7 and Server 2008 R2 onward. Linux back to RHEL/CentOS 6, including 32-bitWindows 10, 11, and Server 2012 R2 onward. RHEL 7 and later, no 32-bit [7]
Multi-tenancyEvery customer is an isolated tenant in the region you pickKibana Spaces aren’t a security feature on their own. The clean option is one deployment per customer [8]
Email and cloud securityBoth in the same tenantCloud posture is a per-asset add-on. No Elastic email security product found [1] [10]
AIask ai in any rule and AI agents started by detections, on the model you chooseAI Assistant and Attack Discovery need Enterprise or Complete [11]

Data and retention

How much data stays searchable in each platform?

LimaCharlie keeps a full year of data hot and fully indexed, at any volume. On Elastic Serverless only a boost window, 7 days by default, is search-ready, and older searches are slower and share capacity with detection rules. On Hosted and self-managed, searchable cold and frozen tiers need Enterprise.

How much data stays searchable in each platform?
CapabilityLimaCharlieElastic Security
Extra metersOutputs beyond same-region Google CloudSupport uplift of 5 to 15% on the whole bill for Gold, Platinum, or Enterprise. Cloud posture per asset. Workflows, Agent Builder, and cross-project search per use [1]
Raw data outStream every event live to S3, GCS, BigQuery, Pub/Sub, Splunk, Elastic, Kafka, syslog, or a webhook. Same-region GCS is free50 GB of egress free per month on Serverless, then $0.05 per GB [1]
Search capacityNothing to scaleOn Serverless, search capacity doesn’t scale up when query load increases [3]

Detection engineering

Which gives MSSPs more reliable detections?

LimaCharlie evaluates each rule on every event as it lands. Elastic rules run every few minutes with a look-back window, and on Serverless most rules stop after 1 minute per run. Elastic’s docs note that a run that stops early can miss alerts.

Which gives MSSPs more reliable detections?
CapabilityLimaCharlieElastic Security
Rule logicProcess trees, sequences, threat-intel lookups, GeoIP, first-seen, and thresholds, plus an AI question inside the ruleCustom query, EQL, ES|QL, threshold, indicator match, new terms, and machine learning [4]
TestingUnit tests on save, plus replay against a year of historyRule preview [4]
ContentEvery rule is editable, plus thousands of community rules converted by AI in one clickA large open rule repo. Editing a prebuilt rule needs Enterprise on Hosted and self-managed [5]
Detection as codeEvery rule syncs from Git to every tenant, with dry-runThe open detection-rules repo and CLI, pushed through the Kibana API per deployment

Endpoint

What does each platform’s endpoint agent include?

LimaCharlie includes full EDR on every endpoint, with every feature on every tier. Elastic includes malware prevention in every tier, puts ransomware, behavior, and memory protection and host isolation in Platinum, and puts the response console in Enterprise or Complete.

What does each platform’s endpoint agent include?
CapabilityLimaCharlieElastic Security
Live response65 sensor commands, memory string search, YARA on live process memory, packet capture, full memory and MFT dumps, and VelociraptorIsolate, kill or suspend a process, get a file (100 MB cap outside Serverless), run a command, upload, scan, and memory dump [6]
PreventionMicrosoft Defender Antivirus, managed from LimaCharlie, plus application allowlisting on Windows and macOSElastic Defend’s own prevention engines
Windows7 through 11 and Server 2008 R2 through 2022Windows 10 and 11, Server 2012 R2 and later. Windows 8.1 marked unsupported [7]
Linuxx86_64, i386, ARM64, and Alpine, back to RHEL/CentOS 6RHEL 7 and later. CentOS 7 dropped from 8.18. No 32-bit [7]

Running it as an MSSP

Which platform is built for multi-tenant MSSP operations?

LimaCharlie isolates every customer in its own tenant by default, with one login and one rule push across all of them. In Elastic, Kibana Spaces aren’t a security feature on their own, so the clean option is one deployment or project per customer, and cross-project search on Serverless needs Complete on every project.

Which platform is built for multi-tenant MSSP operations?
CapabilityLimaCharlieElastic Security
Working across customersOne login across every tenantServerless cross-project search, GA since September 2026. Links up to 100 projects by default, billed separately, and the Alerts page doesn’t show alerts from linked projects [9]
Rolling out changesOne Git template for rules, outputs, playbooks, and AI agentsScripted per deployment or project
IR retainersSleeper-mode sensors at a reduced dormant rate, woken when an incident startsNo dormant mode found

API and AI access

How do AI agents work with LimaCharlie and Elastic?

Both platforms publish APIs, and both offer an MCP server for outside AI assistants. Elastic’s Agent Builder MCP server is generally available on Serverless and in the Elastic Stack since 9.3. The difference is packaging. AI Assistant and Attack Discovery need Enterprise or Complete, while LimaCharlie’s AI agents run on every tier, on the model you choose with a budget cap per agent.

How do AI agents work with LimaCharlie and Elastic?
CapabilityLimaCharlieElastic Security
API coverageEvery console action is an API call: REST API, LimaCharlie CLI, Python and Go SDKs, and an MCP serverElasticsearch and Kibana APIs, plus the Agent Builder MCP server [12]
AI in detection and responseask ai inside any rule, plus AI agents started by detections, on every tierAI Assistant and Attack Discovery need Enterprise or Complete [11]

Pricing model

How do LimaCharlie and Elastic pricing compare?

LimaCharlie is usage-based, with every feature on every tier and a year of retention included. Buy on an annual agreement or month to month, and add products whenever you need them. Elastic Serverless Complete starts at $0.60 per GB of ingest for the first 50 GB, with retention, support, and several features metered separately.

How do LimaCharlie and Elastic pricing compare?
What’s includedLimaCharlieElastic Security
Every feature on every tierYesResponse console, AI, and Workflows need Enterprise or Complete [5]
A year of searchable dataIncludedRetention billed per GB per month. Searchable cold tiers need Enterprise [1] [2]
AI model costsThe model you choose, with a budget cap per agentManaged LLM at $4.50 / $21 per million tokens, or your own connector [11]
Open the pricing calculator →

Why MSSPs switch

Why MSSPs move from Elastic Security to LimaCharlie

01

One price list, every feature

No tier decides whether your analysts can isolate a host, use AI, or search last quarter.

02

A tenant per customer, one platform

Isolation is the default, and your team works across every customer from one console, one Git repo, and one invoice.

03

Detections that fire on the event

Rules evaluate each event as it lands, and the response runs on the endpoint in the same moment.

04

More products to sell

Cloud security and email security live in the same tenant as the SIEM and EDR, so one detection can follow a phish to the laptop to the cloud account.

It’s a very low barrier to entry. I’d say you can go in and experiment with it, and if you don’t like it, that’s fine. And you’re not stuck with it for a year... you don’t have to commit to a thousand endpoints for a year to just give it a shot.

Picture of Paul Ihme
Paul Ihme

Co-founder, Soteria

LimaCharlie was really designed with service providers in mind. It was multi-tenant. More important for me, it was designed to be built upon and extended and expanded.

Picture of Andrew Cook
Andrew Cook

CTO, Recon InfoSec

We’re very much in our SOC, like an MSSP, in the fact that we have multiple customers with multiple different levels. Also, when we’re looking at licensing, getting down to brass tacks, the model for a lot of vendors is not flexible to work with us as we scale up.

Picture of John Strand
John Strand

CEO, Black Hills Information Security

FAQ

LimaCharlie vs Elastic Security: frequently asked questions

Is LimaCharlie a good Elastic Security alternative for MSSPs?
Yes, if you want every customer on the same features with nothing to host. Elastic is a strong fit if your team wants to run its own clusters and work in Elasticsearch.
Can’t we self-host Elastic for free?
The free tier is a capable SIEM with malware prevention. Running it for many customers means owning the clusters, the upgrades, and the on-call, and the features MSSPs sell on, such as the response console, AI, long retention, and cross-cluster search, are in Enterprise, which is quote only for self-managed.
Is Elastic’s search faster?
Elasticsearch is a great search engine. LimaCharlie’s advantage is what happens before you search: rules fire on each event, and the response runs on the endpoint in the same moment.
Can we keep Elastic as our data lake?
Yes. LimaCharlie streams detections and raw events into Elastic, and your team runs detection and response from LimaCharlie.
Is LimaCharlie open source or commercial?
LimaCharlie is a commercial SaaS platform hosted in six regions: USA, Canada, Europe, UK, India, and Australia. A free tier is available for labs and testing.

Compare more tools

How LimaCharlie compares with other platforms

See LimaCharlie running on your own detections

Book a demo with our team, or open a free tenant and connect a test endpoint today.

Sources

Elastic details come from the public sources below, with the date of each source. Product names belong to their owners.

  1. [1] elastic.co/pricing/serverless-security (prices effective Nov 1, 2025; per-endpoint fees removed Mar 23, 2026), Elastic “Serverless pricing and packaging” blog, Nov 1, 2025, and Serverless security billing docs. Read Nov 12, 2026.
  2. [2] Elastic docs: project settings (Search Boost Window) and “Plan rule performance”. elastic.co/pricing/cloud-hosted and /self-managed. Read Nov 12, 2026.
  3. [3] elastic.co/pricing deployment comparison table, read Nov 12, 2026.
  4. [4] Elastic docs: “About detection rules”, “Common rule settings”, “Plan rule performance”. Read Nov 12, 2026.
  5. [5] elastic.co/subscriptions feature matrix, read Nov 12, 2026.
  6. [6] Elastic docs: endpoint response actions, read Nov 12, 2026.
  7. [7] Elastic Defend support matrix, Oct 27, 2026. Elastic Agent support matrix.
  8. [8] Elastic docs: “Manage spaces”. Elastic blog, “Managed security service providers”, Apr 15, 2026.
  9. [9] Elastic blog, “Cross-project search on Elastic Serverless is GA”, Sep 16, 2026. Elastic docs: cross-project search configuration.
  10. [10] Elastic integrations and prebuilt rules index, read Nov 12, 2026.
  11. [11] Elastic docs: AI Assistant and Attack Discovery. elastic.co/pricing/serverless-security (Managed LLM rates).
  12. [12] elastic.co docs: Elastic Agent Builder MCP server (read Nov 13, 2026).